Episode 007 • 09 min 56 sec
Mars After Midnight is a totally optional Catalog game that sets the standard for what the ideal Playdate game should be in terms of looks, sound, and creativity... but it might just not be that much fun to actually play (for Paul, at least).
Check out the Episode:
Show Notes & Transcript
Game Availability: Catalog for $6 - https://play.date/games/mars-after-midnight/
Playdate Podcast: Mars After Midnight - https://podcast.play.date/episodes/s01e29/
Episode Attributions: Pexels Imagery - Cotton Bro, David Nestorov, Kadiremir, Markusspiske, Miguel Rodriguez, Shvets Production, Stephen Leonardi, Tima Miroshnichenko; Video Footage - Mars After Midnight Gameplay: Parts 3 - 5 - YouTube: @DieDevDie, Return of the Obra Dinn Gameplay: Part 1 - YouTube: @ZetaRayZod, Papers Please Gamplay: First Five Days - YouTube: @ign
Episode Transcript: That’s right! You found it! It’s a Playdate podcast focusing on game reviews. And today, we're cranking into Mars After Midnight. I'm your host, Paul Best. And join me while I'm Crankin’ It.
Mars After Midnight. A game where you're running an alien self-help group. And those aliens, they're really into food. So you're going to have to feed them and then clean up after them. But guess what? There's some free loaders that you're also going to have to Just tell them to get the fudge out of here, basically. And it might sound like I'm joking, but I'm not this time because that's the actual gameplay for this weird and just wonderful game. And if you want to check it out, you can pick it up on the catalog today for about $6. Or you can wait till goes on sale and get it for about half the cost. Anyways, let's jump to who made this game.
So Mars After Midnight was developed by Lucas Pope. He was famous for his two big hit indie games, Papers, Please. And then Return of the Obra Dinn. So the story goes that he really loves kind of like minimalistic game design, and he really likes to challenge himself. And when he started learning about the Playdate, he realized he wanted to make a game for it. So this would have been after he created Return of the Obra Dinn, which was a one bit first person investigation game, and he still wanted to work in that one bit space. But it also shows why the gameplay is a little bit more simplistic because he was burned out from working on Return of the Obra Dinn, and he didn't want to do anything too complicated. And he also had children. And so he really wanted to make a game that he thought his children would enjoy playing. And he reinforces this in the credits by adding for the children in it, which is pretty cool. If you want to learn more about, like, how Lucas Pope thinks when he's making his games, which is wildly fascinating, I suggest you check out the official Playdate Podcast by Panic, It's awesome. So let's jump into the mechanics of this game.
So Mars After Midnight has kind of one core gameplay loop that it goes through each day. So the night starts, it's midnight and you open up your self-help clinic and you're advertising for whatever the group is. So you go into this little mini game where you're trying to slap your self-help cartridge into your robot friend so that you can play the self-help group meeting. The very first one you do is for Cyclops is who have anger issues. And so you're going to be standing behind the door in a first person view, and someone will knock on the door. You're going to use the crank to lift up the flap. You're going to look around with the D-pad and make sure that it is a cyclops and that they are angry. And if they pass that check, you're going to go ahead and let them in. If not, you're going to straight up deny them. Once you let that person in, they're going to see that free food and they're going to be like, yo, I'm trying to get down.
So they're going to smash on the food and they may or may not make a mess. And when that happens, you will have to clean the mess. And there's this, like weird kind of invisible grid where you're controlling the arms on different levels and it turns into like an efficiency game where you're trying to pick everything up off the table with both your hands. And then you're going to use the crank to use a brush to clean off the table. And then you have to put everything back down according to the image in the background. And so each self-help group has about six people that are going to come through. And once you get all six people in Then you watch a little cinema and then as they're leaving, if you did a good enough job, you got the right people in. They like the food. They'll give you money according to that. Later on in the game, there might be a merchant who comes that allows you to buy items to help differentiate who should be in the group or not. But at the end of that group session, you get a plan for your next day event. And so you go into this overview of the city and you can look at the different populations you can target. So this could be anything from like Cyclops to aliens to robots to human beings.
You're also going to select what type of item you're going to use to like determine if the people should be in the group or not. And then basically you say, let's go for it. You go to sleep. You get a really cute little cinematic about your main character dreaming about going to Earth, your robot companion dreaming about what he thinks is going to be fun, and then it starts all over again. And I would say it takes about 10 to 15 minutes to get through one of these loops. So pretty simple and not really complicated. And basically once you do it once you know exactly what you're going to get the next time. So let's jump over to my review of this game.
As always, I give two scores. The first is how I think the game works as a game. Like the design, the visuals, the sound. And then the second is how this game actually connected with me emotionally. So on paper, I'm going to give this game an eight. And then at heart, I'm going to give this game a seven. And I'll be honest, I really struggled with what I wanted to personally give it because I'll get into it, but it's a little bit of a roller coaster.
So technically, I think this game is gorgeous. The alien designs are fantastic. The music is very fun and sets the tone for everything. The initial concept of the game is outrageous. I've never, I don't think I could have ever thought of that. And initially, it's really fun but beyond the initial fun of your first gameplay loop, you're going to quickly recognize that every gameplay loop is basically the same. So for a lot of people, I think that's going to bea little rough. And then the last thing I'll say is there's a little bit of a punishing mechanic to this game. So each self-help group has six people you need to service. If you mess up at all and say you only nail five out of the six, you have to do the entire gameplay loop again to get that extra person And if you don't recognize that early on and you do a bunch of groups and only get like four out of six, it's going to be somewhat of a nightmare to have to go back and try to collect every single person.
Where I get to struggling with this game emotionally is I'll be honest, I found the gameplay really boring. The mechanic of opening up the panel and looking at the alien is semi fun, until you realize how many times you're going to have to do it over and over again. And then when you get to the mechanic where you're cleaning up the table, it's about as fun is really cleaning up a table, but you don't have a podcast to listen to. Where I get really conflicted is the characters of the game, which I haven't described yet. You play as this bird character getting just absolutely frustrated with people trashing the table and just not picking up after themselves, And then after a little while, your robot companion, who's running the self-help groups when you go to slap the cartridge in, they might start joking with you and like moving and making it so you can't actually get the cartridge in. And it is kind of funny. And it kind of feels like you're working a dead end job with your friend. Like it gives Clerks vibes, which is kind of really strange.
Like, I wouldn't have expected that. So you start to kind of get into the mindset of these characters, and when you're seeing them dream, you're realizing, like, I've worked a dead end job just to try to, you know, make ends meet so that I can maybe see something cool in life. And then there's a clear flip point in the middle of the game. The merchant sells you a teddy bear and the robot gravitates towards that teddy bear and every time it dreams, it's with his teddy bear companion. And this tiny slice of storytelling gave so much depth to these characters that I was spending so much time with doing this monotonous task you know, I really felt like I went on this weird, boring journey with these characters and that I ended up really falling in love with. And it was all through this, like very minimalistic storytelling. And that experience alone carried so much weight The idea of the gameplay was also so unique that, like, this is where the struggle came in, because I really massively enjoyed that half of the game. But then I didn't actually enjoy playing the game, so, you know, that's where I landed on the seven.
But I guess the last thing I'll say is, should you play this game? I think yes, this is ideally what type of game you want to get on the Playdate. It's so super duper weird. It's a weird concept. It's something you could show your friends if they're, you know, questioning if they should get a Playdate and can be like, dude, just check this out
Anyways, if you like the show, please feel free to like, subscribe or comment or reach out to me on Reddit. I would be interested to hear your take on the gameplay loop. Did you find it boring or not? But anyways, thanks for listening and I'll talk to you later. Bye bye.
Thank you for listening to Crankin’ It produced by Paul Best. Please note that this content is for entertainment purposes only. I am by no means a professional and all these views and opinions are totally my own. Special thanks to our partners for the footage and media in this episode. For attributions and links to the resources. Check the show notes or visit bit.ly/crankin-it. Thank you for listening. Bye bye.
Show Notes & Transcript
Game info: Released in Playdate Season One, Week One
Link 2
Link 3
Episode 003 • 05 min 31 sec
Paul is covering one of the very first games you’ll get as a new Playdate owner. It’s an arcade-style surfing game where you ride the wave... and really, that’s kind of it... and I guess there are a few 360 tricks to pull off, too.
Check out the Episode:
Show Notes & Transcript
Game info: Released in Playdate Season One, Week One
Link 2
Link 3
Episode 002 • 05 min 31 sec
Seriously, skip this episode if you do not care who Paul is. But if you love this device and want to know a little more about the person devoting a bunch of time to it, feel free to hang out with him for a few minutes and get to know who he is.
Check out the Episode:
Show Notes & Transcript
Link 1
Link 2
Link 3
Episode 001 • 05 min 31 sec
Alright, let’s be honest, if you’re here, you probably already know what the Playdate is. But on the off chance that you don’t, or just want to pick up a few fun little nuggets, Paul might be able to shine a bit of light on the strange, tiny, beautiful world of this device.
Check out the Episode:
Show Notes & Transcript
Link 1
Link 2
Link 3
If you made it here, you’re probably interested in the podcast, but if you ever wanted to know a little more about me, here are my back-of-the-baseball-card stats. I’m a middle-aged, longtime gamer with two kids, so my time is limited and super long, newer games can be tough for me to get through. I tend to like shorter experiences, and I’m especially drawn to 8-bit, 16-bit, and now even 1-bit game aesthetics.
I saw an ad for the Playdate a few years before it came out and was immediately interested, but the $200 price point made me hesitate. Still, in an act of delusional defiance, I signed up for the newsletter. Then they basically ghosted me for years until 2025, when I got a random email saying it was available. My ADHD brain locked in, and I was ready to fight with blood, sweat, and tears to get one. Actually, my awesome wife bought me one for Father’s Day, but I still like to think I played a major role in making that happen.
Once I got the device, it ended up being exactly the kind of experience the child in me always wanted, just with a modern twist. It’s unlike any other gaming device I’ve ever owned, and almost no one else seems to have one. So I started this little podcast to join the Playdate community and give back in the only way I know how.
If you’re still with me, and maybe even curious about some of my other projects, check out my other podcast, Hoofin’ It in Hollywood. It’s me and three friends exploring the history of an animal actor, breaking down their most popular movie, sprinkling in some behind-the-scenes movie magic, and playing a few fun games along the way. Learn more on the Hoofin' it in Hollywood website.
Listen to it here:
Doing something cool with Playdate? Whether that’s making a game, building an accessory, writing, reviewing, or anything else in the community, I’d love to hear about it. Reach out and maybe we can team up, talk about it, or feature it on the show.
You can reach me at crankinitreviews@gmail.com.
Motion Array Templates
Premiere Templates Free - Tyler, Spinning Logo Loop - Tyler, Minimal Logo klick - Mr. Freeman, Free Classic Kinetic Titles - Blinque, Dynamic Colorful Slideshow - Blinque, 20 Simple Titles - MinnaPicture